Fear of Driving After a Car Accident: What Research Shows

If your hands tighten on the wheel, or you avoid the car altogether since a crash, you are not overreacting. Fear of driving after a car accident is one of the common symptoms after a collision, which can leave people shaken and vulnerable. A Canadian guideline favours exposure-based treatment for phobias in general. Exposure means facing a feared situation instead of avoiding it, often in graded steps.

Fear of driving after a crash is hard to shake on your own. At The Grief and Trauma Healing Centre, you can book a first session with a therapist.


Why Driving Feels Frightening After a Crash

Fear of driving after a crash makes sense, because a collision can have lasting effects on a person's sense of safety. The car stops feeling like an ordinary tool and starts feeling like the place where things went wrong for you. Fear of driving or riding in a car is a common symptom after a collision, along with avoiding people, places or events that remind you of the accident.

Most people are affected for a brief time, even after a minor collision. After a serious collision, it is not uncommon for people to develop trauma or post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).


How Common Fear of Driving Is After a Crash

Driving phobia is prevalent in people injured in motor vehicle crashes, according to a 2023 review in Disability and Rehabilitation, though its abstract gives no figure. A 2016 study of 72 patients with mild traumatic brain injury cites earlier work putting accident phobia at almost 40% of motor vehicle accident survivors. The figure comes from earlier studies and covers accident phobia, not driving fear alone.


What Research Says Helps With Fear After a Crash

Research on fear of driving after a car accident is limited, so most guidance comes from research on phobias and PTSD more broadly. Four sources stand out:

  • The 2014 Canadian clinical practice guideline names exposure-based treatments as the treatments of choice for specific phobia. Progressive exposures are generally more tolerable, though the guideline found no evidence that gradual exposure works better.
  • The same guideline says both in vivo (real-life) exposure and virtual reality exposure can be effective for specific phobia.
  • In a study of 40 adults with PTSD after motor vehicle accidents, anxious-driving scores fell more after brief exposure-based treatment than on a wait-list.
  • MyHealth Alberta's PTSD page says treatment with counselling and medicines can help PTSD in general, and a doctor can advise on medicines. Ask your doctor if medicines might suit you.

The evidence has real limits. The guideline covers specific phobia in general, not driving fear, and the 40-adult study was a single study of people with PTSD. A 2007 series of six people after serious road accidents reported fewer post-trauma symptoms with virtual reality driving scenarios, but it had no control group. No study cited here tested EMDR for driving fear.


Why Avoidance Can Make Fears Grow After a Crash

Avoiding driving after a collision makes sense to you in the moment. Skipping the highway, taking the bus, letting someone else drive: each choice brings you quick relief. Over time, though, fears have a tendency to grow, and people end up avoiding more and more things in life, according to Alberta's eMentalHealth.ca page on PTSD. A tendency is not a certainty.


EMDR and Somatic Therapy for Trauma After a Collision

For people whose fear of driving comes from collision trauma, Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) is one trauma therapy we offer. EMDR is an evidence-based approach to distress from a painful or traumatic life event, and our EMDR therapy for trauma is one option after a collision. A few things people often want to know about EMDR:

  • EMDR does not erase or change your memories. It aims to reduce the distress you feel about them.
  • You do not have to talk in detail about the crash you want to process, if you'd rather not.
  • EMDR can use tapping or hand-held buzzers instead of eye movements.
  • Deep-rooted issues may take several sessions to work through, and that's normal.

Somatic therapies help promote healing of trauma, grief and anxiety, and our somatic therapy for trauma is another path.

Trauma therapy has several approaches. Our post on how trauma therapy helps the brain heal describes trauma-focused approaches, including prolonged exposure, EMDR and Somatic Experiencing.


Collision Counselling in Edmonton and Sherwood Park

Counselling for fear of driving and other trauma after a collision is available at The Grief and Trauma Healing Centre in Edmonton and Sherwood Park. Help is available to ease the symptoms of the trauma caused by the accident. Ask about online sessions if getting to an office is part of the problem. Our therapists work in several Alberta locations.


Questions About Driving Fear

Questions about fear of driving after a car accident cover minor collisions and virtual reality.


How long does fear last after a minor collision?

Most people are affected for a brief time after a minor collision.

Talk to a therapist if the fear lasts or keeps growing.


Can virtual reality therapy help with driving fear?

Possibly, but not yet proven. The 2023 Disability and Rehabilitation review says more high-quality trials are needed before virtual-reality treatments can be recommended for driving phobia.

Avoiding the car is an understandable way to stay safe. Over time, though, what protects you can start to shrink your life.

If driving still feels frightening after a collision, read about our motor vehicle accident counselling at The Grief and Trauma Healing Centre. Our therapists help people with collision trauma.

If this feels like too much, Alberta's Mental Health Helpline is 1-877-303-2642. For thoughts of suicide, call or text 9-8-8, toll-free, anytime.

Top Draw