Trauma Bonding: Why It Is So Hard to Leave or Let Go

If you feel pulled back toward someone who hurt you, or miss them in a way that makes no sense to you, a trauma bond may be part of the reason. Trauma bonding is a strong emotional attachment to someone who harms you, formed through cycles of harm and closeness. The pull is real. It is also not a sign of weakness.

You don't have to untangle a painful relationship alone. At The Grief and Trauma Healing Centre, you can book a first session with a therapist.


What Is a Trauma Bond?

Researchers describe a trauma bond as forming when harm and closeness keep taking turns and one person holds more power than the other. University of British Columbia researchers tested this idea in 1993. Dutton and Painter's 1993 study of traumatic bonding followed 75 women who had recently left abusive relationships. The more extreme the intermittent abuse, meaning harm that comes and goes, and the bigger the power gap, the stronger the women's attachment to the former partner. Harm that comes and goes is part of what holds the bond together.

Trauma bonds can form in narcissistic abuse, which can begin with love bombing and then slide into devaluation, where care alternates with criticism and contempt. From the outside, the pattern is not always obvious. Closeness in a trauma bond behaves more like weather than climate: warm one week, freezing the next.

The swing between idealization and withdrawal can activate reward and attachment pathways in the brain. That reward response helps explain why separation can feel like withdrawal, even when you logically know the relationship was harmful.


Why Trauma Bonds Are Hard to Break

Trauma bonds are hard to break because leaving means grieving far more than one person. You may grieve the version of them you hoped was real, the future you imagined, the safety you believed you had, and parts of yourself that became smaller along the way. Relief and heartbreak can arrive together.

Missing someone is a human response. Missing them doesn't tell you whether the relationship was safe.

In the Dutton and Painter study, the pull faded only partly. Over six months of follow-up, the women felt about 27% less attachment to their former partners. Less, but not gone.

Some researchers read the bond differently. In a 2023 paper on trauma bonding and appeasement, Bailey and colleagues describe survivors who calm an abuser as a way to adapt to life-threatening situations. Seen this way, what looks like emotional connection is a survival technique, and a normal one.


How Trauma Bonding Relates to Self-Esteem and Trauma Symptoms

Trauma bonding research looks past attachment to self-esteem and trauma symptoms. In the Dutton and Painter study, intermittent abuse and power differences were linked with trauma symptoms and self-esteem, not only with attachment. All three measures were tied to each other, and each one six months later tracked its level just after separation. A larger 2023 study of 354 people in abusive relationships, by Shaughnessy and colleagues, linked traumatic bonding with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) symptoms.

You may feel embarrassed for staying. That embarrassment makes sense. The bond is not your fault, and we want to say that plainly.


Other Reasons People Stay in Harmful Relationships

A trauma bond is only one reason people stay in a harmful relationship. Family violence is complex, and people stay for a variety of reasons. In its article on why women stay in abusive relationships, the Canadian Women's Foundation lists reasons such as these:

  • She fears for her life or the lives of her children.
  • She believes she has nowhere to go.
  • Her immigration status makes leaving harder.
  • She feels ashamed when everyone sees her abuser as a "good guy," and is sure she will be judged and not believed.
  • Family, friends or community have told her they won't support her.
  • She has a disability and depends on her partner for daily care.
  • She loves him, and he seems to regret the violence.

Love and harm can exist in the same relationship, and none of these reasons make someone weak. When it is hard to name what is happening, our guide to the signs of narcissistic abuse in a relationship can bring some clarity.


Staying Safe When Family Violence Is Involved

A safety plan matters when a trauma bond comes with family violence. Ending a relationship is the most dangerous time for someone experiencing family violence, according to the Government of Alberta. Trained staff at Alberta's Family Violence Info Line help people create an emergency escape plan and find safety. The Government of Alberta's family violence supports page lists more options.

Alberta's guidance on family violence includes these steps:

  • Call 911 if you or someone you know is in immediate danger.
  • Pack an emergency bag with identification and important documents, and hide it where the abuser will not find it but it is easy to grab.
  • Create a safety plan, which can be important for safety even when staying.
  • Call or text the Family Violence Info Line at 310-1818, where help is confidential and phone support covers more than 170 languages.
  • Use private browsing mode and clear the browser history after looking up supports, because abusers can get information through online activity.

Counselling for Trauma Bonds in Edmonton and Sherwood Park

Counselling for trauma bonds is part of narcissistic abuse recovery counselling at The Grief and Trauma Healing Centre. Every therapist here has extensive experience or specialized training in grief, trauma, or both.

Therapy here is trauma-informed and attachment-aware, and we pace the work so it respects your capacity instead of pushing past it. Nothing about your reactions is treated as a disorder or a failing. In our narcissistic abuse recovery counselling in Edmonton, therapy explores how trauma bonds and attachment patterns work, along with gaslighting and chronic self-doubt. The work also covers self-trust, emotional boundaries, shame and self-blame, and learning red flags for future relationships.

Depending on what you need, our therapists may also bring in nervous system regulation, somatic approaches, parts work, mindfulness or Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) therapy.

Talking with a therapist about a trauma bond may help if:

  • You keep feeling pulled back toward someone who hurt you.
  • You replay conversations, wondering if you were "too sensitive."
  • You feel confused about what happened.
  • You are just beginning to question the relationship.

Questions About Attachment to Someone Who Hurt You

Readers often ask these three questions about trauma bonds.


Is trauma bonding a proven scientific model?

No, trauma bonding is not settled science, and researchers still debate it. Bailey and colleagues (2023) call it a "hypothetical phenomenon".

The same authors argue that Stockholm syndrome, a label for hostages who seem to bond with captors, does not reflect survivors' experience.


Does a trauma bond mean I am weak?

No, a trauma bond is not a measure of your strength or character.

Shaughnessy and colleagues found that childhood maltreatment and attachment insecurity predicted traumatic bonding. Childhood maltreatment is something that happens to a person, not a flaw in who they are.


Can trauma bonds form outside romantic relationships?

Yes, the term has been used outside romantic relationships. Bailey and colleagues (2023) note it has been applied where clear power differences exist.

Examples include child sexual abuse, intimate partner violence and human trafficking.

Reaching out for support does not mean you missed something obvious or should have left sooner. Asking for help is a way of taking your own experience seriously, at a pace that feels possible, and our article on recovering from narcissistic abuse is one place to start.

Making sense of a trauma bond takes time. When you feel ready, you can learn about individual therapy in Edmonton and Sherwood Park at The Grief and Trauma Healing Centre.

Alberta's Family Violence Info Line is 310-1818 (call or text, 24/7), and the Mental Health Helpline is 1-877-303-2642. Call or text 9-8-8 for thoughts of suicide.

Trauma bonding is the term for a strong emotional attachment to someone who harms you, said to form through cycles of harm and closeness. Dutton and Painter proposed that intermittent abuse, meaning abuse that comes and goes, and unequal power help form it. A trauma bond is one possible reason leaving feels hard, and researchers still debate the term.

At The Grief and Trauma Healing Centre, you can book a first session with a therapist and begin wherever you are.


How Trauma Bonding Forms in Harmful Relationships

In Dutton and Painter's theory, trauma bonding forms when abuse alternates with closeness and one person holds more power than the other. In Dutton and Painter's 1993 test of traumatic bonding, University of British Columbia researchers interviewed 75 women who had recently left abusive relationships. Fifty of them had experienced physical violence. More extreme intermittent abuse and larger power differences went with stronger attachment to a former partner among these women. The data came from interviews and questionnaires.

The Grief and Trauma Healing Centre says narcissistic abuse is not always obvious from the outside and often unfolds subtly. It also names cycles of intense closeness and sudden withdrawal among its patterns.

In the centre's description of narcissistic abuse, a cycle can look like this:

  1. Idealization. Love bombing brings intense closeness.
  2. Devaluation. Care alternates with criticism and contempt.
  3. Withdrawal. Closeness gives way to sudden distance.

The centre says the cycle of idealization and withdrawal can activate reward and attachment pathways in the brain.


Why Trauma Bonds Are Hard to Break

Trauma bonds can be hard to break because attachment to a former partner may linger after a relationship ends. Dutton and Painter's 1993 study included 75 women who had recently left abusive relationships. Their attachment to the former partner had decreased by about 27% after six months. It had lessened but had not disappeared.

In those 75 women, total abuse, how intermittent it was and power differences together accounted for 55% of the variation in attachment at six months. Each measure taken just after separation also correlated with the same measure six months later.

You may feel pulled back toward someone who hurt you, and relief and heartbreak can arrive at the same time. Separation can feel like withdrawal, even when you logically know the relationship was harmful.

Missing someone is a human response, and it doesn't by itself tell you whether a relationship was safe.

In that study of 75 women, attachment to a former partner had lessened but was still present six months after leaving. Nothing in the findings points to a flaw in character.

Bailey and colleagues' 2023 paper offers a different explanation, which it calls appeasement. Survivors in life-threatening situations may appear emotionally connected to a perpetrator to adapt by calming that person.


How Trauma Bonding Relates to Self-Esteem and Trauma Symptoms

Trauma bonding research links attachment to a former partner with trauma symptoms and self-esteem. In Dutton and Painter's 1993 study of 75 women, all three were significantly related. The Grief and Trauma Healing Centre notes that narcissistic abuse dynamics can erode self-trust, self-esteem and emotional stability.

A 2023 study of 354 people in abusive relationships also found that traumatic bonding was positively associated with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) symptoms.

The Grief and Trauma Healing Centre notes that people may feel embarrassed for staying. Embarrassment is understandable, and it doesn't make the bond your fault.


Other Reasons People Stay Besides Bonding

A trauma bond, said to be an attachment to a person who harms you, is only one possible reason people stay in a harmful relationship. Family violence is complex, and people may stay for a variety of reasons. The Canadian Women's Foundation on why women stay lists reasons a woman may stay in an abusive relationship, including:

  • Fear for their own life or their children's lives.
  • Believing there is nowhere to go.
  • Immigration status.
  • Shame, and worry about not being believed when others see the abuser as a good person.
  • Family, friends or community who won't support leaving.
  • Dependence on a partner for daily care because of a disability.
  • Loving a partner who seems to regret the violence.
  • Self-blame after being told the abuse is deserved.

Love and harm can exist in the same relationship. For a list of signs, see The Grief and Trauma Healing Centre's guide to the signs of narcissistic abuse in a relationship.


Leaving or Staying Safely With a Trauma Bond

Leaving a relationship with a trauma bond calls for safety planning. Ending a relationship is the most dangerous time for someone experiencing family violence, and a safety plan can prepare you to leave. Trained staff at Alberta's Family Violence Info Line can help you create an emergency escape plan and find safety. Read the Government of Alberta's family violence supports.

Alberta's guidance on family violence includes:

  • Packing an emergency bag with identification and important documents, and hiding it where the abuser will not find it but you can easily get it.
  • Creating a safety plan, which can also be important in keeping you safe if you stay or cannot leave.
  • Contacting the Family Violence Info Line at 310-1818 by call or text, where help is confidential and phone support covers more than 170 languages.
  • Using private browsing mode and clearing your browser history when you look up supports, because abusers can get information through online activity.

Counselling for Trauma Bonds in Edmonton and Sherwood Park

Counselling for trauma bonds is listed among the focus areas of The Grief and Trauma Healing Centre's narcissistic abuse recovery counselling in Edmonton. Therapy there can include:

  • Understanding trauma bonds and attachment patterns.
  • Working with gaslighting and chronic self-doubt.
  • Rebuilding self-trust and emotional boundaries.
  • Easing shame and self-blame.
  • Learning red flags for future relationships.

Support can make the process less isolating for people actively recovering from narcissistic abuse and for those just beginning to question the relationship. The centre's approach is trauma-informed, attachment-aware and non-judgmental, with pacing that respects your capacity.

Therapists may integrate EMDR therapy for distressing memories when appropriate. The centre's therapists have extensive experience and/or specialized training in grief, loss and/or trauma.


Questions About Trauma Bonding

Trauma bonding raises questions about the evidence, personal weakness and the relationships it applies to.


Is trauma bonding a proven scientific model?

Trauma bonding is not settled science, and researchers still debate it. Bailey and colleagues (2023) call it a "hypothetical phenomenon".

Bailey and colleagues say scarce empirical research supports the claimed positive bond between kidnap victims and captors. Studies such as Dutton and Painter's have tested the theory in abusive relationships.

Bailey and colleagues argue that the label Stockholm syndrome, used for captives who seem attached to captors, does not reflect the survivor's experience.


Does a trauma bond mean I am weak?

A trauma bond is not a measure of character. A 2023 study of 354 people in current abusive relationships found that childhood maltreatment and attachment insecurity predicted traumatic bonding.

Group-level findings describe patterns across people, not any one person's strength.


Can trauma bonds form outside romantic relationships?

The term has been used outside romantic relationships. Bailey and colleagues (2023) note it has been applied where clear power differences exist.

Examples include child sexual abuse, intimate partner violence and human trafficking.

Making sense of a painful relationship doesn't have to happen alone, and individual therapy in Edmonton and Sherwood Park offers a place to begin. The Grief and Trauma Healing Centre works in a non-judgmental way, paced to your capacity.

Top Draw